Fertility

The journey to parenthood is deeply personal—and for many families in California, assisted reproduction through egg donation or sperm donation provides the opportunity to build or complete their families. Whether you’re a couple facing infertility, a single intended parent, or part of the LGBTQIA+ community, reproductive donation can be life-changing. But without the right legal protections, this process can create serious risks.

California is one of the most progressive states when it comes to reproductive rights. Still, navigating the legal landscape requires careful attention, written agreements, and experienced legal guidance. At Minella Law Group, we help clients in San Diego and across California create secure and enforceable egg and sperm donation agreements. This blog will walk you through what you need to know about California’s legal framework for reproductive donation—and how to protect your rights every step of the way.

The Legal Landscape of Reproductive Donation in California

California law recognizes and supports the use of assisted reproductive technologies (ART), including in vitro fertilization (IVF), gestational surrogacy, egg donation, and sperm donation. The state’s legal system is particularly favorable to intended parents, including unmarried couples and individuals of all gender identities and sexual orientations.

However, despite this legal friendliness, clear, written agreements are essential. California courts rely heavily on intent—and that intent must be formally documented. If not, the consequences can be severe: legal battles over parentage, demands for child support from donors, or claims of custody rights years after a child is born.

Unlike some states, California doesn’t have a single codified statute governing all egg and sperm donation scenarios. Instead, the legal framework includes:

• California Family Code §§ 7613 and 7960–7962

• Binding case law emphasizing the importance of written agreements
• Public policy favoring certainty and intent in family formation

Without expert legal advice, donors and intended parents may unintentionally create legal ambiguity that courts will later have to sort out.

Understanding Egg Donation: Legal and Medical Overview

Egg donation involves a woman (the donor) providing her eggs to help another individual or couple (the intended parents) conceive a child. The process typically includes:

• Ovarian stimulation and egg retrieval
• In vitro fertilization using donor eggs and sperm (from a partner or another donor)
• Embryo transfer to a gestational carrier or intended parent

In California, egg donors generally do not retain any legal rights or obligations to children conceived using their eggs—but only if there is a properly executed agreement in place that establishes this intent.

Without a written egg donation contract:

• A donor may have a legal claim to parental rights
• An intended parent may not be legally recognized
• A future child may lack legal clarity on parentage

That’s why legal counsel is required at the outset—to ensure all parties understand and agree to their roles and responsibilities.

Understanding Sperm Donation: California’s Approach to Donor Identity and Rights

Sperm donation in California can occur anonymously through a sperm bank or personally via a known donor (such as a friend, acquaintance, or relative). The key legal consideration here is donor intent, which courts infer from both actions and documentation.

Under Family Code § 7613(b), a sperm donor is not a legal parent if the insemination occurs under the supervision of a licensed physician or surgeon, and there is no intent for the donor to parent the resulting child.

However, if insemination happens outside a medical setting, such as at home, and there is no written agreement clarifying the donor’s intent, the donor may be treated as a legal parent—with all the rights and responsibilities that implies, including custody rights and financial support obligations.

This distinction is critical for known donors. Even if the donor and recipient verbally agree to donor anonymity or non-parentage, those terms are not enforceable without a legally binding contract.

Legal Risks for Donors and Intended Parents

Reproductive donation is not just a medical or emotional decision—it’s a legal one. The risks of proceeding without a formal agreement are substantial:

Risks for Intended Parents:

• Unclear parental rights if no donor agreement exists

• Disputes over custody or contact with the donor

• Potential court battles if the donor later changes their mind

• Challenges establishing legal parentage (especially for LGBTQIA+ couples or single parents)

Risks for Donors:

• Unintended parental rights or obligations

• Financial responsibility, including child support

• Future contact or legal disputes if boundaries aren’t defined

• Unwanted legal entanglement years after the donation

In California, intent is everything—and intent must be documented.

Why Every Reproductive Arrangement Needs a Written Agreement

California courts treat assisted reproduction cases based on documented intent. Without a signed, written agreement, courts may default to biological parentage, creating consequences no party anticipated.

Every egg or sperm donation arrangement should include a custom legal contract that outlines:

• The purpose of the donation

• The rights and responsibilities of each party

• The financial terms (e.g., compensation, reimbursement)

• Provisions for future contact (or lack thereof)

• Terms for disclosure of medical information

• Methods for resolving any future disputes

• Explicit waiver of parental rights by the donor

At Minella Law Group, we draft and review these contracts to ensure full compliance with California law and to protect the interests of all parties involved.

Key Elements of a Legally Enforceable Egg or Sperm Donation Agreement

A thorough agreement under California law should address the following:

1. Clear Intent

The contract must affirm that the donor has no intent to parent and waives any parental rights or responsibilities. Likewise, intended parents must affirm that they intend to assume full legal parentage.

2. Parental Rights Assignment

The agreement must designate who will be recognized as the child’s legal parents and whether there will be any second-parent or step-parent adoption proceedings.

3. Medical and Genetic Disclosure

The donor should provide a full health history, and the agreement should include how future medical updates will be handled if needed by the child or parents.

4. Compensation Terms

Compensation for egg donors is typical; sperm donors are less frequently paid but may be reimbursed for expenses. All financial terms should be clearly stated and comply with California ethical standards.

5. Confidentiality and Contact

The parties should define whether the arrangement will be anonymous, open-identity, or allow for future contact—and how that will be managed or limited.

6. Dispute Resolution

Contracts should include provisions for mediation or arbitration before any litigation—ensuring that private matters stay out of court when possible.

7. Timing and Withdrawals

Agreements often allow either party to withdraw from the arrangement before any medical procedure takes place but not afterward. These terms must be clearly written.

California Law: Parental Intent, Presumptions, and Public Policy

California courts strongly favor the recognition of intended parentage over biological connection—but only if the documentation supports this intent.

Important principles:

• Family Code § 7613 protects donors from legal parentage if conditions are met

• Courts prioritize contractual clarity and written agreements

• Without proper documentation, biological connection may override intent

California public policy supports the ability of all individuals—regardless of gender, marital status, or sexual orientation—to become legal parents through assisted reproduction. But that policy hinges on following the legal process correctly.

Known Donors vs. Anonymous Donors: Unique Legal Issues

Known donors are legally riskier than anonymous ones because:

• Relationships may evolve, leading to changed expectations

• There is more room for ambiguity without a clearly worded agreement

• The donor may later seek contact with the child

• Courts may perceive ongoing involvement as evidence of parental intent

If you are working with a known donor—especially a friend or family member—it is even more critical to put all terms in writing. Verbal promises are not enforceable in California courts.

Anonymous donors through reputable clinics generally pose fewer risks, as those facilities require signed legal documents and ensure medical oversight, which limits legal exposure.

When Things Go Wrong: Legal Disputes and How to Avoid Them

Despite everyone’s best intentions, disputes do arise. Common triggers include:

• A donor who wants contact with the child
• An intended parent who fails to complete legal steps to establish parentage
• A breakdown in communication or misunderstanding of agreement terms
• Changing laws or interpretations over time

Avoiding these issues starts with:

• Retaining experienced legal counsel
• Drafting custom, detailed agreements
• Keeping open, honest communication among all parties
• Following up with post-birth legal steps (like parentage orders or adoption if needed)

The Role of a Reproductive Law Attorney in Protecting Your Rights

Egg and sperm donation may begin in a doctor’s office—but they end in a legal file. A reproductive law attorney ensures that:

• All agreements are customized and enforceable

• Your parental rights (or lack thereof) are clearly established

• The agreement complies with California law and public policy

• Potential problems are anticipated and addressed

• The legal path to parenthood is secure and recognized

At Minella Law Group, we offer legal services tailored to the reproductive needs of modern families. We represent both donors and intended parents, ensuring fairness, privacy, and protection from future disputes.

Minella Law Group’s Approach to Secure Reproductive Agreements

We believe that the foundation of every family should be secure—and that includes legal protection. At Minella Law Group, our reproductive law team:

• Drafts custom egg and sperm donation agreements

• Reviews and revises agreements from agencies or clinics

• Advises on parentage establishment post-birth

• Represents donors, recipients, and intended parents

• Offers flat-fee options for uncontested arrangements

• Provides confidential legal consultations to help you start with clarity

We bring empathy, efficiency, and excellence to every reproductive law matter we handle.

Consult Minella Law Group for Reproductive Law Support

If you’re considering egg or sperm donation in California, don’t take legal risks. Whether you’re a donor or intended parent, the best time to protect your rights is before the process begins.

📞 Call Minella Law Group today at 619-289-7948 to schedule a confidential consultation with one of our family law specialists. We’ll listen to your concerns, assess the situation, and create a clear strategy tailored to your goals.

📝 Prefer email? Fill out our online contact form and a member of our legal team will get in touch with you promptly.