In Child Custody & Visitation, Domestic Violence Restraining Orders

Using Domestic Violence Restraining Orders to Protect Custody Rights in California

paper with a legal seal at the top and words below

How DVROs Can Secure Safety and Legal Custody for Survivors and Their Children

In California family law, few tools are more powerful—or more urgent—than a Domestic Violence Restraining Order (DVRO). When one parent has been subjected to abuse or threats of harm, a DVRO can provide immediate protection while also shaping the long-term outcome of a custody case. These orders are not only about personal safety—they are often the key to preserving parental rights, securing legal and physical custody, and breaking the cycle of trauma for children.

Many parents facing domestic violence worry about how to protect themselves and their children without escalating the conflict or risking retaliation. Others may be unsure whether their experiences “count” as abuse under the law. California’s family courts take domestic violence seriously—and when used correctly, a DVRO can help you build a strong foundation for custody and co-parenting decisions rooted in safety and stability.

This article explains what a Domestic Violence Restraining Order is, who can get one, how it affects custody, and what parents need to know when seeking or responding to one in family court.

What Is a Domestic Violence Restraining Order?

A DVRO is a court order that protects a person from abuse, threats, harassment, or violence by someone they have a close relationship with—such as a spouse, partner, co-parent, or family member. It can be requested as part of a family law case (like a divorce or custody action) or on its own.

California defines “domestic violence” broadly under the Domestic Violence Prevention Act (DVPA). Abuse includes:

  • Physical violence or attempts to harm

  • Sexual assault
  • Threats of violence
  • Emotional abuse or coercive control
  • Harassment or stalking
  • Destruction of personal property
  • Disturbing the peace of the protected party

Importantly, disturbing the peace includes patterns of controlling, intimidating, or isolating behavior—even when no physical violence is present. This broad definition ensures survivors are not excluded simply because they didn’t report bruises or broken bones.

Who Can File for a DVRO?

You can seek a DVRO if the person you are seeking protection from is:

  • Your spouse or former spouse
  • Someone you live with or used to live with
  • Someone you have dated or had a romantic relationship with
  • A co-parent (even if never married)

  • A close family member (like a sibling, in-law, or parent)

You can also request a DVRO on behalf of your children if they are being directly abused or exposed to abuse in the home.

What Does a DVRO Do?

A Domestic Violence Restraining Order can include a wide range of protections, such as:

  • Stay-away orders (requiring the restrained person to stay a set distance away from you, your children, your home, your workplace, and their school)
  • No-contact orders (prohibiting calls, texts, emails, or other forms of communication)
  • Exclusive use of the family home (forcing the abuser to move out)
  • Custody and visitation orders
  • Firearm restrictions
  • Child support or spousal support orders
  • Orders to attend batterer’s intervention or counseling

DVROs can last for up to five years, and may be renewed permanently. A temporary restraining order (TRO) is often granted first, usually without a full hearing, and is later followed by a more formal evidentiary hearing where both sides can present evidence.

How Does a DVRO Affect Custody?

This is where the impact of a DVRO becomes especially significant. California Family Code §3044 creates a rebuttable presumption that a parent who has committed domestic violence should not have sole or joint custody of their child.

In practical terms, if you obtain a DVRO against your child’s other parent, the court will assume they are not fit to share custody unless they can prove otherwise. The court must prioritize the safety of the child and the protective parent over shared parenting arrangements.

This legal presumption shifts the burden onto the restrained parent, who must demonstrate:

  • They have completed a batterer’s intervention program (if applicable)
  • They are not a risk to the child or co-parent
  • Shared custody is in the best interest of the child
  • They have complied with the order and demonstrated change

Until then, the court may limit them to supervised visitation, no visitation, or restricted parenting time. In some cases, visitation may be suspended altogether.

Can You File for Custody and a DVRO Together?

Yes. In fact, it is often strategically advisable to do so. When you file a DVRO request, you can also ask for temporary child custody orders and exclusive control of the home. These requests are often granted on an emergency basis pending the full hearing.

By combining your custody request with your restraining order, you can:

  • Prevent your abuser from removing the child
  • Create immediate structure and predictability for the child
  • Establish yourself as the primary parent early in the case
  • Set the tone for later custody evaluations or mediations

California law empowers the court to make temporary custody orders as part of the DVRO process, and these orders can later become permanent in the final custody judgment.

What Evidence Do You Need?

To obtain a DVRO, you must show that abuse occurred—not just that you were uncomfortable or stressed. Evidence may include:

  • Text messages or emails showing threats, control, or harassment
  • Police reports or 911 calls
  • Medical records
  • Witness declarations
  • Photos of injuries or property damage
  • Testimony from therapists, teachers, or family members
  • Journal entries or logs documenting the abuse
  • Evidence of your child witnessing or reacting to the abuse

If the abuse occurred in front of your children or negatively impacted their well-being, that is especially relevant. Courts are increasingly aware of how domestic violence harms children, even if they are not directly targeted.

What Happens at the DVRO Hearing?

After the temporary order is granted, a formal evidentiary hearing is scheduled—usually within 21 days. Both parties can:

  • Present witnesses
  • Submit exhibits
  • Cross-examine the other party
  • Testify under oath

This hearing functions like a mini-trial. The judge will decide whether to issue a permanent restraining order (typically lasting 1 to 5 years) and whether to grant or modify custody and visitation orders accordingly.

If the restrained party fails to appear, the court can proceed without them.

Can a DVRO Be Used Defensively?

Yes. In some high-conflict divorces, both parties may file competing DVROs. Sometimes, the alleged abuser attempts to “get ahead” by filing first. Other times, the accused parent may feel the allegations are exaggerated or false.

In these situations, courts are careful to evaluate:

  • Who initiated contact

  • Whether there is a genuine threat of harm

  • Whether the allegations are supported by credible evidence

  • Whether the protective order is being used as a litigation weapon

If you’ve been served with a DVRO that you believe is unjustified, you need immediate legal representation to protect your rights and defend your parental relationship.

What If the Court Denies the DVRO?

Even if your request is denied, the act of filing may provide documentation of concerns, a paper trail of attempts to establish safety, and evidence of prior conflict. You may still be able to pursue:

  • Custody modifications
  • Supervised visitation for the other parent
  • Orders for counseling or parenting classes
  • Protective provisions in a custody judgment (e.g., non-disparagement clauses, no-alcohol conditions, third-party exchanges)

In some cases, if the DVRO is denied, the judge may still order Family Court Services mediation, a 730 evaluation, or other assessments to resolve ongoing concerns.

Final Thoughts

Domestic violence and custody are deeply intertwined in California family law. A well-documented, lawfully obtained Domestic Violence Restraining Order can do more than protect your physical safety—it can help secure legal and physical custody, provide stability for your children, and give you a strong foundation as you navigate divorce or co-parenting.

That said, the process is not simple, and it can be emotionally and legally complex. Filing for a DVRO—especially alongside a custody request—requires preparation, clarity, and legal strategy.

At Minella Law Group, we help survivors of abuse protect themselves and their children with skill, compassion, and precision. Whether you’re seeking protection or defending against false claims, we understand the nuances of these cases and the lasting impact they have on families.

 

If You Need Protection, Don’t Wait. We’re Here to Help.

 

If you’re in danger or concerned about your child’s safety, a Domestic Violence Restraining Order may be the first step toward reclaiming control and securing custody.

📞 Call Minella Law Group today at 619-289-7948 to schedule a confidential consultation with one of our family law specialists. We’ll listen to your concerns, assess the situation, and create a clear strategy tailored to your goals.

📝 Prefer email? Fill out our online contact form and a member of our legal team will get in touch with you promptly.

We’ll help you protect what matters most—your safety, your children, and your future.

 

 

In Child Support

Navigating 2025 California Child Support Laws

In the intricate tapestry of family law, few matters carry as much significance as child support. It is a legal obligation that transcends financial transactions, intertwining the lives of parents and the well-being of their children.

In 2025, the landscape of child support undergoes profound transformations, shaped by legislative amendments that prioritize fairness, transparency, and the dynamic needs of modern families.

 

Understanding Child Support

Child support is a legal obligation that ensures both parents contribute financially to the well-being of their children, even if they are not living together. The primary purpose of child support is to provide for the child’s basic needs, including food, shelter, clothing, education, and healthcare. It is a fundamental aspect of family law designed to safeguard the best interests of the child and promote financial stability within separated or divorced families.

Child support is not merely a legal obligation; it is a commitment to the future of our children. The intricacies of these obligations have been further refined through critical revisions to California’s Child Support Guidelines in 2024. This guide aims to unravel the intricacies of these changes, empowering both custodial and non-custodial parents with the knowledge to navigate the evolving system effectively.

 

What Needs to be Disclosed to Calculate Child Support

Calculating child support involves a detailed examination of both parents’ financial situations to determine a fair and equitable contribution. Various factors are taken into account, and disclosure of specific information is crucial for an accurate assessment. Key elements that need to be disclosed include:

Income: Both parents are required to disclose their income, encompassing wages, bonuses, investments, and any other sources of financial gain. Net disposable income, after mandatory deductions such as taxes and health insurance premiums, is typically considered for a more accurate reflection of available resources.

Employment Information: Details about employment, including job stability and any changes in employment status, are essential. This information helps in understanding the reliability of income sources.

Assets and Liabilities: A comprehensive overview of assets, such as real estate, vehicles, and financial accounts, is necessary. Additionally, any outstanding debts or liabilities may impact the overall financial picture.

Living Expenses: Understanding the living expenses of both parents is vital. This includes rent or mortgage payments, utilities, and other regular expenditures that may affect the ability to contribute to child support.

Custody Arrangements: The custody arrangement plays a significant role in determining child support. The amount of time each parent spends with the child can impact the financial obligations.

Special Needs and Extraordinary Expenses: If a child has special needs or requires additional financial support for extracurricular activities, education, or healthcare, these factors should be disclosed for a more accurate calculation.

Full and honest disclosure is crucial in ensuring that child support orders are fair and representative of the parents’ financial capacities. Failure to provide accurate information can lead to legal consequences and may undermine the well-being of the child.

 

Processes for Obtaining Child Support

Obtaining child support typically involves several steps within the legal system. While the specifics may vary by jurisdiction, the general process includes:

Filing a Petition:

The custodial parent initiates the process by filing a petition for child support with the family court or the California Department of Child Support Services (DCSS). This document outlines the details of the case, including information about the child, the custodial and non-custodial parents, and the requested child support amount.

Service of Process:

The non-custodial parent is officially notified of the child support proceedings through a legal process known as “service of process.” This ensures that the non-custodial parent is aware of the legal action and has an opportunity to respond.

Response and Financial Disclosure:

The non-custodial parent is given an opportunity to respond to the petition, providing their financial information and addressing any concerns. Both parents may be required to complete financial affidavits or disclose relevant documentation.

Mediation or Court Hearings:

In some cases, parents may be encouraged to participate in mediation to reach an agreement on child support terms. If an agreement is not reached, the case may proceed to a court hearing, where a judge will consider the evidence and make a determination on child support.

Child Support Order:

If an agreement is reached or the court makes a decision, a child support order is issued. This order specifies the amount of child support to be paid, the schedule for payments, and any other relevant terms.

Enforcement:

If the non-custodial parent fails to comply with the child support order, enforcement measures may be taken. These can include wage garnishment, property liens, suspension of licenses, and other legal actions to ensure compliance.

It’s important for both parents to engage in the process with transparency and a focus on the best interests of the child. Seeking legal advice and assistance, particularly from family law attorneys, can help navigate the complexities of child support proceedings and ensure a fair resolution.

 

2025 Adjusted Income Guidelines

California’s Child Support Guidelines are undergoing crucial revisions to create a fairer system for calculating child support payments. These adjustments are significant and can impact the amount of support you’re either entitled to receive or obligated to pay.

The revised guidelines take a more nuanced approach to income calculation, considering both parties’ net disposable incomes. This involves calculating actual take-home pay after mandatory deductions. The updated income brackets include widening ranges to account for the high cost of living in various areas of California. Distinctions are made between different regions within the state, recognizing economic diversity.

Additionally, calculations now consider multiple children and the financial needs specific to each child’s age.

These adjustments aim to provide a more equitable system where child support payments align more closely with each parent’s financial capacity and the realistic needs of the children involved. It’s crucial to stay informed about these changes, as they reflect a commitment to creating a system that adapts to the dynamic nature of family structures.

 

2024 Revised Enforcement Measures

In 2024, California’s child support system undergoes not only recalibrations in the calculation of payments but also a robust enhancement of enforcement measures. The aim is to ensure that child support obligations are met promptly and fully, fostering an environment of accountability and responsibility.

Electronic Income Withholding Orders (E-IWOs)

A pivotal shift in the enforcement landscape comes with the increased prevalence of Electronic Income Withholding Orders (E-IWOs).

These orders streamline the withholding process, making it more efficient for employers to redirect owed funds directly from a parent’s paycheck to the child support agency. The move towards automation serves to reduce errors and accelerates the transfer of payments, ensuring that children receive the necessary support without unnecessary delays.

Integrated Database for Tracking Payments

To enhance transparency and tracking capabilities, a new integrated database is introduced. This database is designed to closely monitor payment patterns, providing real-time tracking of child support transactions. Any missed or late payments trigger prompt enforcement actions.

This advanced tracking system not only minimizes the incidence of payment lags but also ensures a more proactive approach to enforcement.

Swift Intervention by Law Enforcement Agencies

The revised enforcement measures empower law enforcement agencies to intervene more quickly in cases of non-compliance. Immediate income withholding for all new and modified child support orders ensures a swift response to ensure that child support obligations are met.

This proactive approach is aimed at minimizing delays and ensuring that children receive the support they are entitled to without undue hardship.

Advanced Tracking Systems Triggering Enforcement Actions

Advanced tracking systems are implemented to closely monitor payment patterns and automatically trigger enforcement actions. If a parent consistently falls behind on payments or fails to meet their child support duties, these systems enable quicker responses. The goal is to address non-compliance promptly and take appropriate measures to ensure that financial support is provided for the well-being of the child.

Additional Powers Granted to the California Department of Child Support Services

The California Department of Child Support Services is granted additional powers to enforce compliance. This includes the authority to place liens on property and bank accounts to collect overdue child support. In practical terms, this means that if a parent falls behind on payments, the state can take legal action by making a claim against their assets until the debt is settled. This added enforcement measure serves as a significant deterrent against non-compliance.

Consequences for Persistent Non-Compliance

Persistent non-compliance with child support obligations can lead to more severe consequences.

The revised enforcement measures include the possibility of license suspension or being barred from certain government benefits for parents who consistently neglect their child support duties. These consequences emphasize the seriousness with which non-payment issues are treated under the updated laws.

A Balancing Act

While the focus remains on creating a supportive environment for both parents and children, the revised enforcement measures strike a balance by taking non-payment issues more seriously than ever before. By minimizing the exploitation of loopholes and upholding the rights of children to financial support, these measures aim to reinforce the idea that supporting one’s child is not just a legal obligation but a moral and societal responsibility. The changes are designed to foster compliance, accountability, and, ultimately, the best interests of the child.

Impact on Custodial Parents

The 2024 changes have significant implications for custodial parents, affecting how support payments are received. With the introduction of E-IWOs, income withholding becomes automated, resulting in more punctual payments. The integrated database monitors payment patterns in real-time, offering increased transparency and triggering enforcement actions promptly

The intended benefits for custodial parents include improved payment regularity, reduced administrative burden, enhanced enforcement support, and less personal involvement in collection efforts. These changes aim to alleviate financial challenges and ensure the child’s welfare remains a top priority.

Impact on Non-Custodial Parents

Non-custodial parents will experience a shift in how child support payments are processed and enforced. The introduction of E-IWOs streamlines the withholding process, ensuring prompt and consistent payments. The new integrated payment database accurately tracks financial contributions, reducing the chance of disputes over payment histories.

Non-compliant payers should be mindful of stringent enforcement actions, including garnishment of wages, property seizure, license suspension, and possible jail time. Proactive engagement with the California Department of Child Support Services is crucial to avoiding these measures, especially in cases of financial hardship

 

Changes in Child Support Add-Ons Allocation: A Closer Look

In the ever-evolving landscape of family law, one of the significant amendments to child support statutes pertains to the allocation of add-ons. Beyond the basic support provided for the child’s day-to-day needs, child support add-ons play a crucial role in addressing specific, often unavoidable, additional expenses that contribute to a child’s overall welfare. These add-ons go beyond the standard child support amount and are designed to cover essential elements that may not be included in the basic calculation.

  1. Uninsured Medical Expenses:

One significant category of child support add-ons involves uninsured medical expenses. These include healthcare costs that are not covered by insurance, such as co-pays, deductibles, and medical treatments that may fall outside the scope of regular insurance coverage. Children often require medical attention beyond routine check-ups, and these add-ons ensure that both parents contribute to covering these unforeseen or non-insured medical expenses.

  1. Childcare Costs:

Childcare is another crucial aspect addressed by child support add-ons. The costs associated with childcare, including daycare expenses or costs related to babysitters or after-school programs, are considered add-ons. Recognizing that parents may need assistance in covering the expenses associated with ensuring the child’s care and supervision, these add-ons aim to distribute the financial responsibility fairly between both parents.

  1. Educational Expenses:

Educational expenses, such as school fees, extracurricular activities, and tutoring, are also covered by child support add-ons. Education plays a vital role in a child’s development, and these expenses are considered essential for their growth and enrichment. The allocation of funds for educational purposes ensures that both parents contribute to providing a well-rounded learning experience for the child.

  1. Special Needs:

Children with special needs may incur additional expenses related to their unique requirements. Child support add-ons take into account the extra costs associated with medical care, therapy, adaptive equipment, or any other necessities specific to the child’s condition. These add-ons acknowledge the diverse needs of children and aim to provide adequate financial support to meet those needs.

  1. Extracurricular Activities:

Participation in extracurricular activities, such as sports, arts, or other enrichment programs, is encouraged for a child’s overall development. Child support add-ons may cover the costs associated with these activities, ensuring that both parents contribute to providing opportunities that go beyond the basic necessities and contribute to a child’s personal and social growth.

 

Current Law and Customary Practice:

Under the previous legal framework, the customary practice for allocating add-ons, such as uncovered medical expenses and childcare costs, leaned towards an equal division of 50% between both parties. While this approach provided a standardized method, an alternative option existed, allowing the allocation to be based on the parties’ relative net incomes.

New Law:

In September 1, 2024, a transformative change will be implemented through Family Code Section 4061(a), reshaping the approach to child support add-ons allocation. The new law states that these add-ons shall now be apportioned according to the parties’ relative net incomes, unless a specific request for an alternative allocation is made or the court determines a different division. 

This means it can be 90/10, 80/20, or whatever the breakdown is. The point is that for the first time we have an option to deviate from 50/50.  

Breaking down the process further, Section 4061(b) delineates the steps involved in computing child support and addressing any spousal support. Firstly, child support is calculated, and any spousal support ordered is subtracted from the payor’s gross income and added to the payee’s gross income. Following this, any child support ordered is subtracted from the payor’s net income but not added to the payee’s income.

Implications of the New Allocation Approach

This shift in allocation methodology holds profound implications for parents navigating child support proceedings.

By tying the allocation of add-ons to the parties’ relative net incomes, the new law aims to create a more equitable distribution that reflects the financial capacity of each parent accurately. This move recognizes the diverse economic circumstances of parents and ensures that the financial responsibilities associated with add-ons are proportionate to their individual abilities to contribute.

Navigating the Changes

As parents adapt to these changes, it becomes imperative to stay informed about the nuances of the new allocation approach. Understanding the intricacies of computing child support, considering spousal support, and recognizing the implications on net incomes are crucial steps in navigating the evolving landscape of child support laws.

 

Managing Child Support Under the 2024 Changes

Navigating the complexities of child support under these changes requires attention to detail and proactive engagement. Familiarize yourself with E-IWOs, leverage the integrated payment database, and stay proactive to avoid enforcement actions. Communication with the California Department of Child Support Services is vital to staying in good standing and ensuring timely support for your children’s education, healthcare, and general welfare.

Adapting quickly to the updated California child support laws in 2025 contributes positively to your child’s well-being and future. Embrace the new systems, stay informed, and fulfill your responsibilities to provide the best for your children.

 

For more information or to schedule an appointment, call us at (619) 289-7948. We look forward to helping you.

In Divorce

Tracing Separate Property in Divorce: How to Prove What’s Yours

estate planning

In California divorces, determining whether an asset is community or separate property can have major financial consequences. The distinction directly impacts whether the asset must be split with your spouse or retained as your own. One of the most important tools for protecting separate property in a divorce is the process known as “tracing.”

Tracing is the method by which a party demonstrates that a particular asset—or portion of an asset—can be clearly and convincingly identified as their separate property. This becomes especially critical in high-asset divorces, where investments, real estate, businesses, and retirement accounts may have been acquired or grown during the marriage but contain separate property origins.

This blog breaks down what tracing is, when it’s necessary, how it works under California law, and what you can do to strengthen your case if you need to prove that something is rightfully and exclusively yours.

Understanding the Basics: Community vs. Separate Property

California is a community property state, meaning that any property acquired during the marriage is presumed to belong equally to both spouses. However, there are important exceptions.

Separate property includes:

  • Property acquired before the date of marriage

  • Property received as an inheritance

  • Assets obtained through gifts to one spouse only

  • Proceeds from separate property, provided they’re kept separate

  • Property designated as separate via a valid prenuptial or postnuptial agreement

While the rules may seem straightforward, the real challenge arises when separate and community funds have been commingled—or mixed—in a way that makes ownership unclear. That’s where tracing comes in.

What Is Tracing in Divorce?

Tracing refers to the legal and forensic process of tracking the origin and path of assets to prove that they were initially, and remain, separate property—despite coming into contact with community property.

California courts require clear, credible evidence to support separate property claims. Simply asserting, “That house was mine before we married” is not enough. You must show:

  1. The source of the funds used to acquire or grow the asset

  2. That the funds or asset remained segregated or identifiable

  3. That you did not transmute the asset (i.e., change it into community property by intent or action)

If you can’t trace it, you risk losing it—or having it split in divorce.

Common Situations Where Tracing Is Required

Tracing is necessary in a wide range of divorce scenarios, including:

Real Estate Purchased Before Marriage but Paid Off During Marriage

If you bought a home before marriage, it’s initially separate property. But if the mortgage was paid down with community funds during the marriage, the community may have acquired an interest in the equity—especially under the Moore/Marsden rule (explained below).

Inheritance or Gift Received During the Marriage

Inheritance is considered separate property. But if you deposited that money into a joint account and then used it for shared expenses, you may need to trace it to reclaim it.

Business Started Before Marriage

If you owned a business before marriage but continued operating it during the marriage, the community may be entitled to a share of its growth unless you can trace the value back to separate sources.

Investment Accounts and Retirement Plans

Stocks, crypto, and retirement accounts often mix premarital and marital contributions. Tracing is necessary to isolate what portion of the account remains separate.

Methods of Tracing: Direct vs. Indirect

There are two primary methods for tracing separate property in California: direct tracing and family expense tracing (also called indirect tracing).

Direct Tracing

Direct tracing involves showing that a specific asset was purchased with separate funds and remained separate throughout. This requires:

  • Detailed financial records (e.g., bank statements, wire transfers, checks)
  • Proof that separate funds were used
  • No commingling with community funds
  • Clear intent to keep the asset separate

Example: You inherited $100,000 from your parent and used it to buy a rental property. You kept the inheritance in a separate account and used it directly for the down payment. You did not add your spouse’s name to the deed or use joint funds for improvements. This asset may be successfully traced and confirmed as separate property.

Family Expense Tracing (Indirect Tracing)

This method is used when separate and community funds have been combined. It assumes that community funds are spent on family expenses first, leaving separate property intact.

Example: You deposited an inheritance into a joint bank account. Over time, the community spent money on groceries, vacations, and bills. You then used remaining funds to buy a car. You may argue that the remaining funds were your separate property because community expenses depleted the community portion.

This method is more complicated and may require expert testimony from a forensic accountant.

The Moore/Marsden Rule: Mixed Real Estate Contributions

When one spouse purchases a home before marriage (or with separate funds), but community property is later used to pay down the mortgage, the Moore/Marsden formula is used to determine each party’s interest in the home.

The rule allows the community estate to gain an interest in the property proportionate to the amount of principal reduction made with community funds. The appreciating value is then shared based on that ratio.

Example:

  • You bought a home before marriage for $400,000

  • During the marriage, community funds paid off $100,000 of principal
  • The house is now worth $800,000

Using Moore/Marsden, your spouse may claim a share of the appreciation tied to that $100,000, even though your name is on title.

A proper tracing analysis can reduce or limit that claim.

What Happens If You Can’t Trace the Asset?

If you’re unable to trace the asset back to a separate property source with clear and convincing evidence, the court will presume it is community property. This means:

  • You may have to split the asset with your ex

  • You could lose the full value of an inheritance, premarital investment, or business

  • You may be ordered to pay out 50% of something that was originally yours

In high-net-worth divorces, this can mean hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars lost due to poor documentation.

Tracing Best Practices

If you have any asset that you believe is separate property, follow these best practices to strengthen your claim:

  • Keep separate property in separate accounts

  • Avoid commingling inheritance or premarital funds with joint money

  • Maintain copies of bank records, title documents, and contracts

  • Consult a forensic accountant early in the divorce

  • Identify assets that may require tracing during your initial disclosures

  • Consider filing a preliminary tracing report to preserve your claims

  • Avoid transferring or retitling assets during separation

Working with a lawyer experienced in asset division can help ensure your tracing strategy is properly documented and presented.

Tracing and Settlement Strategy

In many divorces, tracing becomes a powerful negotiation tool. You may choose to:

  • Waive certain claims in exchange for other assets
  • Use strong tracing evidence to justify keeping 100% of a disputed asset
  • Agree to a reduced split of an asset that’s only partially traceable
  • Offer a buyout based on traced vs. untraced percentages

These discussions are best handled with the support of your legal team and financial expert. A well-executed tracing claim can significantly improve your net result in property division.

When to Bring in a Forensic Accountant

If your case involves any of the following, consider hiring a forensic accountant:

  • Large commingled accounts
  • Long marriage with complex financial history
  • Business ownership with separate and community contributions
  • Real estate purchased before marriage but used by both spouses
  • Mixed investment portfolios or retirement plans

These experts can trace transactions across years, prepare expert reports for court, and testify on your behalf. Their findings can make or break a case involving valuable assets.

Final Thoughts

Tracing separate property is one of the most effective—but often underused—strategies in California divorce. If you received an inheritance, owned a business, or bought property before your marriage, you may have the legal right to keep it. But without proper tracing, you risk losing it to the community pot.

Don’t wait until court to protect your assets. Be proactive, organized, and strategic with your tracing claims.

At Minella Law Group, we specialize in high-asset divorce and have extensive experience helping clients trace and protect their separate property. Whether through negotiation or litigation, we can help ensure you keep what’s rightfully yours.

 

Need Help Proving an Asset Is Separate Property?

📞 Call Minella Law Group today at 619-289-7948 to schedule a confidential consultation with one of our family law specialists. We’ll listen to your concerns, assess the situation, and create a clear strategy tailored to your goals.

📝 Prefer email? Fill out our online contact form and a member of our legal team will get in touch with you promptly.

Our team is ready to guide you through the tracing process and fight for the financial outcome you deserve.

In Child Welfare

School Reports and CWS: What Gets Flagged

Understanding How Educators Report Suspected Abuse and Neglect in California

You pack your child’s lunch, send them off to school, and go about your day—only to receive a phone call that stops you in your tracks. Someone from your child’s school has contacted Child Welfare Services (CWS), reporting suspected abuse or neglect. You’re shocked, confused, maybe even outraged. How could this happen? What triggered the report? What does it mean for your custody and your family?

This situation is more common than many parents realize. In California, teachers, school counselors, administrators, and staff are all mandated reporters, meaning they are legally required to report any reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect. Their role isn’t to investigate or confirm anything—that’s CWS’s job. But if they see something or hear something that raises concern, they must file a report.

In this blog, we’ll explain why and how schools report families to CWS, what types of behaviors or statements get flagged, how these reports affect custody cases, and how you can protect your rights if you’re contacted by CWS due to something that happened at school.

Who Are Mandated Reporters?

Under California law, mandated reporters are professionals who are legally obligated to report suspected child abuse or neglect. This includes:

  • Teachers

  • School counselors

  • Principals and administrators

  • Nurses and health aides

  • Classroom aides

  • Coaches and extracurricular staff

  • Bus drivers and other school employees

These individuals do not need to have proof of abuse—only a “reasonable suspicion” that abuse, neglect, or harm may be occurring. Once that threshold is met, they must file a report with CWS or law enforcement.

Failure to report can result in criminal penalties, loss of employment, and civil liability. As a result, many school employees err on the side of caution, making a report even if they’re unsure of what’s happening at home.

What School Behaviors Might Trigger a CWS Report?

Children may unintentionally say or do things at school that raise red flags for staff. Some of these concerns may reflect real issues, while others may stem from misunderstandings, stress, or common childhood behavior.

Common triggers for CWS reports from school staff include:

  • Unexplained bruises, cuts, or injuries

  • Wearing the same clothes repeatedly or appearing dirty

  • Extreme hunger, hoarding food, or sudden weight loss

  • Comments about being hit, spanked, yelled at, or locked in a room

  • Saying they’re scared to go home

  • Frequent tardiness or absences

  • Reports of witnessing violence or drug use at home

  • Age-inappropriate sexual behavior or comments

  • Dramatic changes in mood or personality

  • Chronic fatigue, falling asleep in class

  • Lack of medical care or failure to treat known conditions

It’s important to understand that schools are trained to look for patterns rather than isolated events. A single missed lunch or scraped knee probably won’t result in a report. But repeated indicators of neglect or fear may lead staff to notify CWS out of concern.

Can a Parent’s Discipline Style Trigger a Report?

Yes. California law prohibits certain types of corporal punishment and harsh discipline, even if the parent believes it’s justified. If your child tells a teacher that you “spank them with a belt,” “wash their mouth out with soap,” or “locked them in their room,” that may lead to a report—even if the context is misunderstood or exaggerated.

Cultural norms, parenting philosophies, and tone all play a role. Unfortunately, what one family sees as discipline, a teacher might see as excessive force or emotional abuse. That’s why it’s crucial to be mindful of how your child might describe events at home and to talk with them openly about safe, respectful boundaries.

How Are Reports Filed?

When a school staff member suspects abuse or neglect, they must file a Suspected Child Abuse Report (SCAR) with CWS or law enforcement. The report includes:

  • The child’s name and age

  • The reporter’s observations or concerns

  • Dates and times of any incidents

  • Any known family background

  • Information about siblings or other children in the home

The report is confidential. In most cases, you will not be told who made the report—even if you suspect it was a teacher or staff member. This is to protect the reporter from retaliation and to encourage honesty in the reporting process.

What Happens After a Report Is Filed?

Once the SCAR is filed, CWS will screen the report to determine whether it meets the criteria for investigation. If it does, a caseworker may:

  • Contact the school for more information

  • Visit your home (announced or unannounced)

  • Interview your child privately at school

  • Interview you and any other household members

  • Review medical, school, or counseling records

  • Inspect your home for safety issues

Depending on the findings, CWS may:

  • Close the case with no action (unfounded)

  • Offer voluntary services (such as parenting support)

  • Open a formal case in juvenile dependency court

  • Recommend temporary custody or visitation changes

Even if no court case is filed, the fact that CWS was involved may influence future custody proceedings—especially if you’re already in family court.

How Do School Reports Affect Custody Cases?

In ongoing custody cases, school-initiated reports can have a significant impact. Family court judges are extremely cautious when it comes to child safety, and a recent or ongoing CWS investigation—even if unfounded—can lead to:

  • Supervised visitation

  • Temporary loss of custody

  • Requests for parenting evaluations (730 evaluations)

  • Mandatory therapy or parenting classes

  • Delays in finalizing custody orders

School staff may also be called to testify in court or submit written observations during family law proceedings. If a teacher or counselor expresses concern about a child’s behavior, well-being, or fear of a parent, it can shift the judge’s perception of the case.

What If the Report Was a Misunderstanding?

Many school-based reports stem from innocent misunderstandings. A child might say something shocking that’s taken out of context, such as:

  • “My mom tied me up!” (referring to being buckled in too tightly)

  • “My dad locked me in the room!” (referring to time-out)

  • “We didn’t eat dinner last night!” (because they didn’t like the food)

Children often exaggerate, confuse events, or repeat things they hear from others. But schools are not allowed to filter or assess the truth of these statements—they are legally required to report and let CWS investigate.

If this happens to your family, do not panic. Most investigations end with a finding of no wrongdoing. However, how you respond can shape the outcome and future custody decisions.

What Should You Do If a School Calls CPS on You?

If you’re notified that CWS is investigating a school-initiated report:

  • Stay calm and respectful with the caseworker and school staff

  • Cooperate, but don’t overshare or admit guilt

  • Contact a family law attorney immediately

  • Document everything: what was said, when, and by whom

  • Gather evidence of your parenting: photos, routines, schedules, school involvement

  • Avoid retaliation or emotional conversations with teachers or your child

If you believe the report was made in error, you may request a written statement for the file or seek an opportunity to clarify with the school. However, trying to “confront” staff or deny your child’s experiences often backfires.

Can You Prevent False or Unnecessary Reports?

You can’t stop schools from reporting if they’re concerned—but you can build strong relationships that encourage communication before it gets that far.

Some tips:

  • Attend parent-teacher conferences and stay engaged with your child’s school life

  • Be responsive to concerns raised by teachers or counselors

  • Maintain consistent school attendance and communication

  • Provide contact information and emergency plans in case of family disruptions

  • Be proactive about health issues, learning differences, or behavior challenges

When schools feel connected to the family, they are more likely to reach out informally before escalating to CWS.

Final Thoughts

School-based referrals to Child Welfare Services are serious, but they are not uncommon—and they are not necessarily an accusation of abuse. Educators are mandated to report anything that could indicate harm, even if their information is limited or the concern is ultimately unfounded.

If your child’s school has filed a report, take it seriously. Cooperate respectfully, protect your legal rights, and consider seeking legal support to avoid custody disruptions. How you respond in the first days and weeks of the investigation may shape the outcome more than the report itself.

At Minella Law Group, we help parents in San Diego navigate CWS investigations, protect their custody rights, and address school-related concerns before they spiral into family court crises.

If a School Report Has Affected Your Custody, We Can Help

Whether you’re under investigation or just trying to protect your parenting relationship, you don’t have to go through this alone. We’ll help you respond, rebuild, and protect your child’s well-being and your rights.

📞 Call Minella Law Group today at 619-289-7948 to schedule a confidential consultation with one of our family law specialists. We’ll listen to your concerns, assess the situation, and create a clear strategy tailored to your goals.

📝 Prefer email? Fill out our online contact form and a member of our legal team will get in touch with you promptly.

Your child’s safety matters. So does your voice. Let us help you be heard.

In Child Welfare

Reunification Plans: What Are They and How Do They Affect Custody

Understanding Reunification in California Juvenile Dependency Cases

When a child is removed from a parent’s care by Child Welfare Services (CWS), the immediate concern for most parents is whether they will ever regain custody. In California, the juvenile dependency system is designed not just to protect children—but to help families repair, rebuild, and reunify when it is safe to do so.

That’s where reunification plans come into play. These legally mandated service plans give parents the opportunity to address the issues that led to removal, with the ultimate goal of bringing their child home. But not all parents understand how reunification plans work, how they relate to custody rights, or what happens if the plan isn’t successful.

This article breaks down what a reunification plan is, how it impacts custody and visitation, and how parents can navigate the process effectively in California dependency court.

What Is a Reunification Plan?

A reunification plan—sometimes called a “case plan” or “family reunification services”—is a court-ordered program created after a child is removed from a parent’s care in a juvenile dependency case. These plans are designed to correct the issues that led to the child’s removal so that the parent can regain custody safely.

Under California’s Welfare and Institutions Code §361.5, reunification services are offered to most parents when a court finds that:

  • A child has been abused, neglected, or is at risk of harm, and

  • The court believes reunification is possible with appropriate intervention

The services in the plan are tailored to the specific needs of the case and typically include steps like:

  • Parenting education

  • Substance abuse treatment or testing

  • Domestic violence counseling

  • Mental health evaluations or therapy

  • Anger management

  • Case management and social worker visits

The court may also include requirements for consistent visitation, safe housing, employment, or participation in the child’s school or medical care.

Who Gets a Reunification Plan?

In most cases, both parents are offered reunification services, even if only one was the subject of the original allegations. The law presumes that keeping families together is in the child’s best interest whenever possible.

However, reunification services may be bypassed under certain conditions—especially if the parent has a history of severe abuse, a prior failed reunification case, or has been convicted of specific violent crimes. In those situations, the court can move directly toward permanency planning, such as guardianship or adoption.

If you’re unsure whether you’re eligible, a dependency court attorney can review your case and determine whether reunification is the appropriate path forward.

How Long Does Reunification Last?

Reunification plans are time-sensitive. California law sets strict time limits for how long a parent can work toward reunification before the court must consider alternative permanent plans for the child.

The general timelines are:

  • 6 months for children under age 3

  • 12 months for children age 3 and older

  • Up to 18 months in exceptional cases, if reunification is likely

These deadlines begin on the date of the child’s removal, not when the parent starts participating. If you delay services or miss court hearings, you may lose precious time in the reunification window.

That’s why early compliance is critical. Parents who jump into services, attend every hearing, and build a record of participation are more likely to regain custody within the court’s timeframe.

What Happens at Review Hearings?

Once the reunification plan is in place, the court will schedule regular review hearings—typically every 6 months. At each hearing, the judge will consider:

  • Is the parent complying with the case plan?

  • Has the parent made measurable progress?

  • Is the child’s safety ensured?

  • Is reunification likely within the next review period?

The court relies heavily on reports from the assigned social worker, the minor’s attorney, and any involved therapists or evaluators. Your behavior between hearings matters—missed appointments, failed tests, or late visits can all be cited as lack of progress.

If the court finds that progress is sufficient, it may expand visitation or begin trial placements where the child returns home part-time. If progress is not made, the court may terminate services and move to a permanent plan such as guardianship or termination of parental rights.

How Reunification Affects Custody

During the reunification process, custody is suspended or significantly restricted. The child may be placed with the other parent, a relative, or in foster care while the court evaluates each parent’s ability to safely resume care.

Your goal is to use the reunification plan to demonstrate that you can meet your child’s physical, emotional, and developmental needs. Custody may be restored gradually—beginning with supervised visits, moving to unsupervised time, overnights, and eventually full reunification.

At the end of a successful reunification case, the court will issue what’s called an “exit order,” which creates a custody and visitation structure for the future. That order becomes enforceable in family court.

However, if reunification fails, the court can:

  • Award custody to the non-offending parent

  • Place the child in long-term foster care or guardianship

  • Terminate parental rights and move toward adoption

This is why engaging with the plan early and consistently is so important. The reunification plan is not just a checklist—it’s your legal opportunity to preserve your parental rights and regain custody.

What If Only One Parent Is Reunifying?

In many cases, only one parent is accused of abuse or neglect. If the other parent is deemed safe and suitable, the child may be placed with that parent under California Welfare and Institutions Code §361.2.

Even if you are the non-custodial parent at the time of removal, you may gain full physical custody while the other parent works through reunification. That said, the court may still expect you to:

  • Support the reunification process

  • Ensure the child attends court-ordered visitation

  • Cooperate with services if concerns arise

If the other parent is successful, custody may be shared again. If not, the court may convert your physical placement into a permanent custodial arrangement.

What Happens If You Fail the Reunification Plan?

If the court determines that reunification is not possible within the allowed time, it may terminate services and schedule a WIC §366.26 hearing, where a permanent plan is selected. That may include:

  • Legal guardianship with a relative or foster parent

  • Adoption by a caregiver or relative

  • Long-term foster care (rare)

If the court moves to terminate your parental rights, your ability to seek custody later may be permanently lost.

However, parents who show late but meaningful progress can sometimes request additional time—especially in cases involving mental health recovery or substance abuse treatment. Your attorney can help you argue for more time if you can prove that reunification is likely soon.

Tips for Successfully Completing a Reunification Plan

  1. Start Immediately
    Don’t wait for your attorney or social worker to chase you. Sign up for classes, attend therapy, or get evaluated right away.

  2. Show Up for Everything
    Every visit, every test, every meeting counts. Your consistency builds credibility with the judge and caseworker.

  3. Keep Detailed Records
    Log every interaction, appointment, and completed task. Save certificates of completion, sign-in sheets, and progress notes.

  4. Communicate Respectfully
    Be polite and professional with all involved parties, even if you disagree. Avoid conflict with your ex, the social worker, or the monitor.

  5. Stay Sober and Stable
    If substance abuse or mental health issues were part of the case, prioritize recovery. Attend meetings, follow medication protocols, and document everything.

  6. Maintain a Safe Home
    Secure housing with enough space for your child, working utilities, and a clean, stable environment.

  7. Work With Your Attorney
    Be honest with your lawyer, follow advice, and prepare for each court hearing as if it’s your only chance to tell your story.

What Happens After Reunification?

If reunification is successful and your child is returned to your care, the court will usually keep the case open for a short time to monitor stability. If everything goes well, the case is closed and the custody order becomes permanent.

This exit order then transfers to family court and becomes enforceable under the Family Code. It can be modified in the future if circumstances change, but it is often treated as the new baseline for all custody decisions going forward.

If you were the non-custodial parent before reunification, and you now have custody, you’ll need to understand how to manage parenting time, co-parenting responsibilities, and transitions—all while maintaining the progress you demonstrated to the court.

Final Thoughts

Reunification plans are a powerful legal tool that gives parents a chance to address concerns, rebuild trust, and regain custody of their children. While the process is not easy, it is absolutely possible with the right mindset, support, and legal guidance.

At Minella Law Group, we help parents in San Diego and throughout California navigate every stage of the reunification process. Whether you’re just starting your case plan or are approaching a key review hearing, we’re here to advocate for you, protect your rights, and help you bring your family back together.

Ready to Reunify With Your Child?

Don’t leave your family’s future to chance. If you’ve been ordered to complete a reunification plan or are worried about losing custody, we can help you understand the system and build a strategy that works.

📞 Call Minella Law Group today at 619-289-7948 to schedule a confidential consultation with one of our family law specialists. We’ll listen to your concerns, assess the situation, and create a clear strategy tailored to your goals.

📝 Prefer email? Fill out our online contact form and a member of our legal team will get in touch with you promptly.